Prep Titans logo
Prep TitansMDCAT 2026
All articles
Guidance 6 min read2026-11-06

How to Build a Safe, Borderline and Reach College List

When merit lists come out, you will be asked to rank colleges in order of preference. The order you choose matters. A good list protects you from missing out entirely while still giving you a shot at your best options.

The idea: three layers

Split the colleges you are considering into three groups, based on your aggregate and last cycle's closing merit.

  • Reach: your aggregate is below last cycle's closing merit, but not by much. You would love these and have a real if smaller chance.
  • Borderline: your aggregate is within about 1 point below the closing merit, or just above it. These could go either way.
  • Safe: your aggregate is at or above last cycle's closing merit. You have a strong chance.

Our medical colleges directory uses the same idea. Enter your aggregate and each college gets a "Within reach", "Borderline" or "Unlikely" tag.

Step 1: Get your aggregate

Work it out with the MDCAT aggregate calculator, or learn the maths in how the MDCAT aggregate is calculated.

Step 2: Filter the directory

Open the directory and set your filters. For example, if your aggregate is 88.5 and you want MBBS in Punjab, you can open a link like 88.5 aggregate, Punjab, MBBS, reachable only. Change the numbers to your own. The filters stay in the address bar, so you can save or share the link.

Step 3: Fill the three layers

Aim for a spread, not a pile. A sensible starting shape is:

  • A few reach colleges at the top
  • A solid middle of borderline colleges
  • Several safe colleges at the bottom

There is no magic number. The point is that if the top of your list does not work out, the rest still catches you.

Step 4: Order by preference, not by fear

Within the list, put colleges in the order you truly prefer them. In most merit-based systems you are considered for your higher preferences first, so putting a college you like more above one you like less costs you nothing if you qualify for both. Check the exact rules for the authority you apply through, because processes differ.

Step 5: Add what merit does not show

Before you lock the order, compare colleges on things merit cannot tell you. Clinical exposure, faculty, hostel, fees and location all matter. The guide how to choose a medical college covers nine of them.

Step 6: Keep a plan for the worst case

Ask yourself honestly what you will do if none of your preferences come through. Options include a private college you can afford, BDS, or a retake. Read MBBS vs BDS if you are unsure about dental.

Important limits

Last cycle's closing merit is a guide, not a forecast. Cutoffs rise and fall with the number of applicants, the difficulty of the paper and how many seats are on offer. Treat a "Within reach" tag as encouragement and an "Unlikely" tag as a reason to look wider, never as a guarantee either way.

Also remember that quotas, reserved seats and different rules for different boards can change who competes for which seat. Read the official admission notice for the authority you apply through.

Worked example

Take a student with an 88.5 aggregate in Punjab. They might shortlist one or two colleges slightly above their number as reach picks, several colleges close to it as borderline picks, and several clearly below it as safe picks. Each tier is made from the directory, using real closing merits.

Now they have a list where each choice is a decision, not a gamble.